Nick's Char Pit Menu (Updated September 2025)

Welcome to Nick's Char Pit, a beloved American restaurant nestled at 22 Middletown Ave in North Haven, CT. Known for its comforting and hearty fare, Nick's offers a menu that celebrates the classic tastes of America. From the moment you step in, the friendly ambiance invites you to indulge in a culinary experience crafted with care.

The star of the menu is undoubtedly the cheeseburger, lauded by patrons for its juicy perfection, especially when topped with sautéed onions. Guests rave about the massive lobster roll and the big papa burger, which can easily satisfy the appetite of a family of four. Pair your meal with their famous fried shrimp or rich New England clam chowder, both praised for their remarkable flavors.

One of the standout aspects of dining at Nick's is the efficient counter service, allowing you to order and find a cozy table swiftly. Customer favorites like the steak sandwich and rice pudding shine, with loyal patrons often reminiscing about flavors that evoke fond childhood memories. With warm staff and an inviting atmosphere, Nick's Char Pit is not just a meal, but a gathering spot that brings people together to share good food and great moments. Whether you’re a local or just passing through, a visit is a must—you won't be disappointed!